Category Archives: Legal/Ethical Dilemmas for Your Consideration

Is substance abuse by a parent proof positive of child abuse or neglect?

This dilemma is inspired by a recent episode of the wonderful dramatic show “In Plain Sight”: In the show, divorcing parents with two school-aged children each accuse the other of abusing and neglecting their children. The husband, who is a … Continue reading

Posted in Legal/Ethical Dilemmas for Your Consideration, Thoughts About Legal/Ethical Decision Making in Mental Health | Tagged , , , , | Leave a comment

Can misleading advertising violate informed consent?

Happy new year everyone! During a trip to Albuquerque recently as I was driving along the highway I noticed a billboard promoting a law office. The sign said, among other things, that the firm was “powerful.” If one considers the … Continue reading

Posted in Legal/Ethical Dilemmas for Your Consideration, Thoughts About Legal/Ethical Decision Making in Mental Health | Tagged , | Leave a comment

How far “to go” about a colleague’s unethical/unlawful behavior.

A well-known and standard ethics text offers the following scenario: A clinical social worker at a community mental health center has a caseload that includes clients who have been diagnosed with symptoms of schizophrenia and affective disorders. The social worker’s … Continue reading

Posted in Legal/Ethical Dilemmas for Your Consideration | Tagged , | Leave a comment

Managing a potential conflict of interest in mental health services

Consider this scenario: you are a direct service provider offering mental health counseling to individuals and families. A young woman and her mother visit your office seeking assistance with their personal relationship. You elect to assess them together during their … Continue reading

Posted in Legal/Ethical Dilemmas for Your Consideration | Tagged , , | 3 Comments

Freedom of speech in school settings: A fundamental right

A story from today’s headlines reveals that a 16-year-old student has been banned by his Ohio school district from wearing a shirt with the insignia of a fish and the slogan “Jesus is Not a Homophobe.” The student’s explanation for wearing the … Continue reading

Posted in Legal/Ethical Dilemmas for Your Consideration | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment

Revisiting the duty to report suspected child abuse: another case scenario

It is truly remarkable how many standard ethics textbooks present fictional factual scenarios in which the reader is urged to read each scenario and make a decision about whether the facts are enough to warrant a report to a child protective service … Continue reading

Posted in Legal/Ethical Dilemmas for Your Consideration | Tagged , , | 1 Comment

Legal issues in clinical supervision

As readers of this blog have noticed, I have presented a series of professional dilemmas derived from similar case scenarios in well-known ethics treatises. As with the other dilemmas I have presented, I wish to make the case that many … Continue reading

Posted in Legal/Ethical Dilemmas for Your Consideration, Thoughts About Legal/Ethical Decision Making in Mental Health | Tagged , , , | 1 Comment

Revisiting the duty to report sexual abuse

On 12/9/11 I posted a dilemma entitled “the duty to report sexual abuse” in which I presented a hypothetical dilemma which raises questions associated with the law governing the duty to report child sexual abuse. In light of an interesting … Continue reading

Posted in Legal/Ethical Dilemmas for Your Consideration | Tagged , , , | 2 Comments

Adolescent sexual activity, birth control, and confidentiality

Happy new year, everyone! I’m back with my take on a practice scenario that has been portrayed in several different ways in several ethics textbooks as an “ethical dilemma.” As with most of the examples pesented on this blog, this dilemma in actuality … Continue reading

Posted in Legal/Ethical Dilemmas for Your Consideration | Tagged , , | Leave a comment

Exploring the right of privacy and self-determination

It is an oft-cited position presented in this blog and website that the law based decision making system offered here provides the most effective and efficient approach to the resolution of practice dilemmas in the mental health professions. A frequent … Continue reading

Posted in Legal/Ethical Dilemmas for Your Consideration | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment